"To
Self-Audit . . . Or Not?"
|
Key Indicators, Drivers, Blocks & Block Removers For Nonprofit
Leaders
The Opportunity
Deep support for the work of nonprofits depends on deep trust between
donors and nonprofits. Nonprofit self-audits can help build that trust.
The self-audit referred to here, goes beyond a traditional financial audit
to one that addresses seven performance areas and involves feedback from
board members, staff, major donors and other stakeholders. Those seven
areas are:
- Relationship /Connectedness
- Mission/Goals/Feedback
- Current Project Assessment
- Effectiveness/Efficiency/Sustainability
- Leadership
- Volunteer Management
- Donor Direction of Gifts
To self-audit is an act of courage. There are many motivations, some
proactive and some reactive for self-auditing . . . and some risks. Before
taking this step, read each indicator and assess what's possible and what's
at risk.
Directions
Place a check mark next to each of the indicators that address a factor
of importance to your nonprofit.
A Self-Audit of our nonprofit would likely:
- Create a breakthrough in trust and accountability with stakeholders
- Respond to a donor complaint or alleged wrong doing
- Earn community respect by self-auditing without being asked
- Lift a veil of misunderstanding between donors and nonprofits
- Proactively pinpoint our nonprofit's "proud's" and "do better's"
- Help us sleep better knowing our house is in order
- Correct an error, integrity lapse or ethical lapse
- Make it easier to do our job effectively
- Assure a check and balance between staff and board
- Put rigor and heart back into conscious nonprofit management
- Differentiate our nonprofit in the minds of donors and funding agencies
- Tap the savvy and bond board members and staff so they become part
of the solution
- Make us a role model and "way-shower" for other organizations
- Build donor trust so they can open their minds, hearts and checkbooks
- Make it easier to attract and keep top board members
- Allow us to conduct our own due diligence before someone does it for
us
- Deliver predictability and transparency so everyone knows where the
money is going and how dollar allocation decisions are made.
Caveat: "If you can't afford to hear the answer . . . don't
ask the question." Before conducting a self- audit, ask yourself,
"Can we afford to hear the answer and then will we commit the resources
to make essential changes?" If not, you may want to delay self-auditing
until a later date. Asking for feedback and not acting on any of it can
irrevocably alienate those who complete the audit.
Next Steps
So what are the forces in your organization that would be "drivers" for
a positive self-audit process? How will you mobilize the "drivers"? What
are the "blocks" that you will need to honor and take into account? How
will you mobilize the drivers and address the "blocks"? Use the template
below to focus your efforts.
Analysis of Self-Audit Drivers and Blocks
| Drivers |
Blocks |
Driver Mobilizers |
Block Removers |
| Example:
Requested by board
|
Example:
Fear of loss of donors
|
Example:
Ask board who they else they want to invite
to participate
|
Example:
Involve key donors in the self-audit design
and review of results
|
| |
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
Your Self-Audit Implementation Steps
|
Action
|
By When By Whom
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
1.
|
|
|
|
| 2. |
|
|
|
| 3. |
|
|
|
| 4. |
|
|
|
|
©2002,
Charles B. Maclean, PhD All Rights Reserved
©2003, PhilanthropyNow, All Rights Reserved
|
|